Skip to main content

What Agentic Coding Really Is: From Autocomplete to an Agent That Does the Work

For a long time, AI in programming was mostly a Tab key. You started typing, the editor guessed the rest of the line, and you accepted it or kept typing. Handy, but you were always the one driving.

Today the same kind of tool can read a ticket, work its way through the repository, change files, run the tests, read the error message and try again. When you come back, a branch with a finished proposal is waiting. That is no longer autocomplete. That is agentic coding.

The term is everywhere right now, which is exactly why it has become blurry. Sometimes it means a chat window in the editor, sometimes a bot that opens pull requests, sometimes just "something with AI". In this post I sort it out: what agentic coding is, what it is not, which misconceptions refuse to die, and what really works today.

The key terms up front

Before we dive in, a quick look at the terms that often get mixed up:

  • Code completion (autocomplete): The tool suggests the next characters or lines while you type. It reacts to what you are writing and usually only knows the context around your cursor.
  • Chat assistant: You ask a question or paste in code and get an answer. Applying, inserting and testing it is up to you.
  • Coding agent: An AI system that works with tools. It can read and change files, run commands in the terminal and evaluate the results.
  • Agentic coding: The way of working where you give a coding agent a goal and it works its way there over several steps on its own. You steer through guidelines, context and review, not through every single line.
  • Vibe coding: Generating code by feel and accepting it with little or no review, as long as it somehow runs. That is something different from agentic coding, more on that below.

Examples of coding agents are Claude Code, OpenAI Codex, the agent mode in Cursor and the coding agent from GitHub Copilot. The details differ, the basic principle is the same.

Why this is happening now

Letting machines write software is not a new idea. What is new is that several things have matured at the same time:

  • Working with tools is more reliable. Modern models can read files, run commands and interpret the output sensibly instead of just producing text.
  • Longer tasks stay manageable. An agent can work through several steps in a row without losing the thread along the way (most of the time, at least).
  • The environment provides feedback. Compilers, type systems, linters, tests and Git are already there. For the agent they act like guardrails that immediately tell it whether a step worked.

This also explains why agents do so much better in well-maintained projects with tests and types than in grown codebases without a safety net. The quality of your project environment shapes the quality of the results.

The autonomy ladder

The easiest way to understand the difference is to picture a ladder. Each rung gives the tool a bit more independence.

LevelWho steers?How does it work?
AutocompleteYou, line by lineYou type, the tool completes
ChatYou, question by questionYou ask, copy, test, ask again
Agent in the editorBoth of you togetherThe agent changes files, you confirm steps
Autonomous agentThe agent, you review the resultTask in, pull request out

Important: more autonomy is not automatically better. Which level fits depends on the task, the risk and your experience with the tool. In everyday work you switch between the levels all the time.

What happens inside an agent

Technically, a coding agent is not magic. It is a loop. It looks roughly like this:

  1. Understand the goal: The agent reads your task and the project context.
  2. Plan: It considers which files might be affected and in what order to proceed.
  3. Act: It reads code, changes files or runs commands.
  4. Observe: It looks at the result, for example test output, linter messages or compiler errors.
  5. Correct: It adjusts its approach and repeats the loop until it is done or gets stuck.

The key difference to a chat: the agent gets feedback from reality. It sees whether the code compiles and whether the tests are green. A chat model guesses, an agent tries and checks.

In its engineering post "Building effective agents", Anthropic describes a helpful distinction. In a workflow, the language model and tools are orchestrated through predefined code paths. In an agent, the model dynamically directs its own process and its use of tools. The post also advises starting with the simplest solution and adding complexity only when it pays off. That applies to your everyday work too: not every task needs an agent.

An example: the same task, three tools

Imagine an everyday task (simplified example): a table in the dashboard should become filterable by time period.

With autocomplete you write the filter function yourself. The tool completes variable names and standard loops. You look for the right files, and you think about types and tests.

With a chat you describe the problem and paste in the component. You get a suggestion and insert it, the compiler complains, you copy the error back into the chat, and so on. You are the messenger between model and project.

With an agent you describe the goal and the acceptance criteria. The agent finds the table component and the matching data hook, adds the filter, adjusts the types, writes a test, runs linter and tests, fixes a type error and summarizes what it did. You read the diff and decide.

The difference is not that the agent writes better code. The difference is who walks the path between goal and result.

Five misconceptions that refuse to die

1. Agentic coding is vibe coding with better marketing

No. With vibe coding you accept results with little checking. Agentic coding in professional use combines autonomous execution with structure: clear tasks, tests, review and fixed checkpoints. The agent may do a lot, but nothing lands in the main branch unchecked.

2. The agent replaces the developer

It replaces part of the typing work, if anything. The responsibility stays with you. Someone has to decide what gets built, how it fits into the architecture and whether the result is good enough. Those tasks do not get smaller, they get more important.

3. The more autonomous, the better

More autonomy also means more code in less time, and with it more review load. An agent can produce code faster than you can review it thoroughly. That bottleneck shifts from writing to reviewing. Whoever ignores this accumulates errors faster than ever.

4. With the perfect prompt, everything works

Prompts help, but context and guardrails matter even more: a maintained project description, reliable tests, clear conventions and well-cut tasks. A mediocre prompt in a clean project beats a brilliant prompt in a chaotic repository.

5. Agents make everyone faster

This is the most interesting question, and the evidence is mixed. The nonprofit research group METR let experienced open-source developers work on real tasks in their own mature projects in a controlled study. With AI support they took 19 percent longer on average. Beforehand they had expected a speedup of around 24 percent, and even after the work they still believed they had been faster. The authors themselves say the results do not transfer to everything, and the tools have evolved since the study (early 2025).

What I take from this: gut feeling is a poor yardstick. If you want to know whether an agent helps in your own project, try it on concrete tasks and compare.

How widespread is this really?

A look at the numbers helps against the hype. According to the Stack Overflow Developer Survey 2025, with around 49,000 respondents, 84 percent use or plan to use AI tools. At the same time, 46 percent say they do not trust the accuracy of the results. Agents are less widespread: a good third had no plans to use them at all. Those who do use them often report productivity gains, but the figures for code quality are noticeably more restrained.

That matches what many people experience day to day: the technology is useful, but it demands attention. Skepticism here is not a sign of being behind the times, it is a sensible safeguard.

What works realistically today

In my assessment and based on the experience reports so far, agents do well where the task is clear and verifiable.

Well suited:

  • Clearly scoped bug fixes with a reproducible case
  • Adding tests for existing code
  • Mechanical refactorings and migrations across many files
  • Boilerplate, types, configuration and documentation
  • A first exploration of unfamiliar code ("Where is this actually calculated?")

Handle with care:

  • Unclear requirements where only a conversation defines the task
  • Architecture decisions with long-term consequences
  • Security-critical areas such as authentication or payments
  • Anything that cannot be checked automatically

The rule of thumb: the better you can verify the result automatically, the more autonomy you can give. Tests, types and linters are not a side issue, they are the agent’s eyes.

What changes for you as a developer

The work shifts. Less time goes into typing, more into three other activities:

  • Cutting tasks: Small, clearly described tasks with a clear goal produce better results than big wishes.
  • Providing context: Conventions, architecture decisions and commands belong where the agent can find them, for example in a project file like CLAUDE.md or AGENTS.md.
  • Checking results: You read diffs, question assumptions and ask: does this really solve the problem, or just the test?

That sounds like less craft, but it is more of a shift in skills. If you can read code well, describe problems cleanly and keep an overview of systems, you have a clear advantage here.

How to start without chaos

If you want to try agentic coding, a small, controlled start helps:

  1. Pick a harmless task, for example additional tests or a small refactoring.
  2. Work on your own branch, so you can discard everything at any time.
  3. Provide context: How do you run the tests? Which conventions apply?
  4. Read the whole diff before you accept anything.
  5. Note what went well and what did not. That is how you find out where the agent really helps you.

Increase the autonomy only once you have a feel for the strengths and weaknesses of your tool.

Conclusion

Agentic coding is neither a marketing buzzword nor a miracle cure. It describes a real change: the tool no longer just suggests, it acts. It reads, changes, tests and corrects in a loop and gets feedback from the project along the way.

At the same time, the responsibility stays with you. Good tasks, clean context and consistent review decide whether the agent becomes a real gain or just a faster way to create problems.

My advice: try it, but measurably and in small steps. Then you will quickly notice where an agent saves you hours and where you are better off typing it yourself.

Want to bring AI agents into your development process, or need help choosing the right tools? Find out more under AI development, or write to me directly.